Miss Marple’s cleverer sister

A sad, sad, day six years ago, I finished reading everything Agatha Christie had published. Yes, even the Mary Westmacott weepies. Just as I resigned myself to  hanging around her grave waiting for a miracle, I discovered Patricia Wentworth’s Miss Silver mysteries.

book cover of   The Case of William Smith    (Miss Silver)  by  Patricia Wentworth

The Case of William Smith

It’s soon after WWII when we meet William Smith, second-in-command at Tattlecombe’s Toy Bazaar in London. Although William seems perfectly ordinary, down to his commonplace name, he suffers from amnesia. Life before 1942, when he woke up in a German hospital with a head wound, is a blank. William has, however, managed to pull it together. He carves quirky wooden animals for the toy shop, has scraped together the funds to buy a car, and is now in love with the new shop assistant, Katherine, who is beautiful and gentle and willing.

Then, an attempt is made on William’s life, and the only reason can be William’s missing past. Katherine decides to consult Miss Silver.


A retired governess turned private investigator, Miss Maud Silver  is first a lady, at least by her own definition, and then a detective. More British than a Beefeater’s elevenses, Miss Silver dresses drably, believes in breeding and restraint and God and King and good old-fashioned classism. She is clever, oh, preternaturally so, to the extent some police friends believe she hides her broomstick in the hall closet.

Miss Silver is most often compared to Christie’s Miss Marple–both are elderly unmarried British women whose innocuous appearance helps them gather information when more flamboyant characters might fail. But unlike Miss Marple, Miss Silver is a professional.  And while Miss Marple is shrewd, Miss Silver possesses a profound intelligence that her clients often find unsettling; Katherine, for instance, “feels the kind of panic which comes in dreams when you find yourself naked among the clothed.” Yes, Miss Silver could probably rotate a 3X3 matrix in her head while casting off stitches for a woolly jumper.

Tempering Miss Silver’s acuity is her sympathy for her clients. It’s a tad strained, reserved for those fulfilling Miss Silver’s ideas of morality and good behavior, but it’s there, and thank goodness for it, for I wouldn’t like these books as much otherwise.

Furthermore, while Miss Marple plays a lone hand, keeping everyone (including the reader) guessing till the end, Miss Silver works with her protagonists to solve the mystery, and we follow her thought process and actions through the story. Miss Marple’s modus operandi, in essence, is to draw a parallel with some village event—a murdered cabinet minister reminds her of the ne’er-do-well nephew of the fishmonger, and presto! she deduces the identity of the killer. Miss Silver relies on inductive reasoning; presented with a set of facts, she can isolate the possible outcomes with great precision. The suspense in a Wentworth isn’t as much to do with the crime already committed as with the one yet to take place–it’s important to find William Smith’s identity (and that of his would-be assassin) so as to prevent the next attempt on William’s life from succeeding. And to make sure William and Katherine live happily ever after. Every Miss Silver mystery has at its heart a romantic couple (not a romance necessarily). This couple must and will unite; under no circumstances will either party die or prove to be a villain, and if a crime was committed by either, it will have been in ignorance, and with no lasting ill-effects. (Such foreknowledge about the end has never diminished my enjoyment of the books–the romance triumphant is as much part of the series as Miss Silver’s velvet coatee, or the creepy brooch with the hair of her grandparents).

The chief issue I have with Wentworth is her all-too-evident dislike of ambitious women. Her heroines aren’t weak—most exhibit immense strength of character, toil without complaint, and show great loyalty to their loved ones—but they do not prize independence or success. A woman who deliberately plots  to advance her social/financial position through marriage or professional achievement is considered a dangerous unsettling force in Wentworth’s universe, for her ambition usually twists her femininity into something unwholesome.  While Miss Silver is indeed a professional, she is in it to serve Truth and Justice, and definitely not for the money, and you know she’s rather go hatless than advertise.  Modern-day readers who are impatient with such biases may find Wentworth’s heroines hard to digest. And the heroes are of course all tall dominating providers, but you’ve guessed that by now.

Wentworth’s prose, while lacking the depth and beauty of say, a late Sayers, is unfussy and clean, and does the job satisfactorily. Her plots aren’t as ingenious as Christie at her peak, and are sometimes overburdened with tedious detail, but keep me turning the pages.  I’ll stop the faint praise here to assert that the appeal of a Miss Silver mystery chiefly lies in Miss Silver. To watch that mind at work, to savor her critics’ reaction turn from scorn to fear, to smile over the small details of her physical appearance, to startle at and then appreciate her rare wit—these are the reasons I read these books over and over. Miss Silver is an institution, and somewhat to my own surprise, one I’ve grown fond of. And, if I might presume to guess, so might you.


Note: Patricia Wentworth wrote 32 Miss Silver mysteries, starting with Grey Mask (1928). There is very little information about her on the net;  a rather threadbare account of her life may be found at Wikipedia.

This post is my contribution to The Golden Age of Detective Fiction blog tour.

21 thoughts on “Miss Marple’s cleverer sister

  1. I’m so glad to learn about this author. I’d never heard of her before you mentioned her for the Classics Circuit. Her approach sounds rather Sherlock Holmes-ian, which appeals to me more than Marple’s approach to detection. I’ll keep an eye out for Wentworth. Miss Silver sounds like a detective I’d appreciate.

  2. It’s absolutely years since I read a Wentworth, but your great review has encouraged me to start again. I can’t agree about the brooch though. It’s just as well we are all different. I collect mourning/ senimental brooches.

  3. I haven’t heard of her and I’m glad I found her! I love detective fiction and can’t get enough of it!

    Going to look for her now. 🙂 Thanks.

  4. very well written..and
    shall pursue this, i too have finished all of christies’ offerings (including as the weepies as you so well put it)

  5. I had never heard of Miss Silver, but I adore Miss Marple, and have been hanging around Dame Christie’s grave too hoping for a miracle (and thank you- it is such a perfect description of how I feel). Will definitely try to get hold of some of her books.

  6. @ Teresa: I joined the circuit primarily to share my liking for Wentworth’s work, so I’m very glad you’ll be checking her out.

    @Katrina : Thanks.
    My apologies if my wording was offensive to you–the brooch was just so alien to my age/cultural context that I found it odd.

    @A&N : Great! do post when you read one!

    @idli: Thanks! And I’ve never really warmed to the Westmacotts–too studiedly dramatic for my taste.

    @Rayna: Great! I discovered her in England, and I hope you can find some–they are pretty elusive.

  7. Thanks for this review. I don’t think I’ve ever read this particular Miss Silver story, and it sounds excellent. I agree with you – based on the ones I have read, she is much sharper than Miss Marple. Unfortunately, Wentworth is largely out of print in the US, but not in the UK, and Amazon.uk seems to have a fair number of her books available.

    You might enjoy “The Key,” or “The Clock Strikes Twelve,” two other Miss Silver novels I’ve read. Wentworth, I think, is generally underrated. Again, thanks for your positive review!

  8. Ooh, this certainly looks like something I’d love to try! I know exactly what you meant when you wrote about how you felt after reading all the Miss Marple stories – I felt exactly the same way, and dealt with it by re, and re-re-reading many of the stories! They were every bit as charming every time!

  9. @ Les: Glad to meet a fellow Miss Silver reader! I agree Wentworth’s under-rated, and for no good reason, really. I discovered her when I lived in England, but my local (Canadian) library actually stocks a few.
    I’ve read almost all the Miss Silver novels, and William smith is one of the best. do try and get hold of this one!

    @Kamini: I’m a re-reader of Christie too–somehow, knowing the identity of the murderer has never spoiled the experience!

  10. I am an Agatha addict as well and have run through every single one of her booksmany times over. Recently, I came across the ‘Aurora Teagarden’ mysteries by Charlaine Harris.

    Aurora is a four foot eleven librarian, in her 30’s , living in asmall town in the midwest…loads of small town gossip and intrigue…a decent enough replacement for Miss Marple….

  11. Thank you for introducing Miss Silver. I ran out of Christie too. It isn’t quite satisfactory to re-read Poirot all the time (though as delightful as he is).

    Now, I go and hunt for Miss Silver by Wentworth.

  12. I love Patricia Wentworth. Not too fond of Agatha Christie except Miss Marple and Parker Pyne. Miss Silver is better. I have all but 7 or 8 of her books. My top favorite is Anne Belinda which isn’t Miss Silver and then The Case of William Smith. Abe Books has hundreds or thousands of her books from under $4 to over $5000. What I really like is that nice people aren’t murdered and the murderer isn’t someone I like.

    • Jean’s desire for series in which “nice people aren’t murdered and the murderer isn’t someone I like” is also met by Miss Seeton. She may not be as clever as Miss Marple or Miss Silver, but she’s the only one of the three still having adventures (24 at the last count).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s