Breaking Dawn by Stephenie Meyer

I’ve been off blogging for a long time, thanks to my move from Ottawa to Hamilton, ON. The post-move flotsam is finally at manageable levels, and I’m back to Brown Papering again.  

Stephenie Meyer.

Author Stephenie Meyer

I hadn’t heard of Stephenie Meyer or the Twilight Series till a few months ago–an omission akin to not realizing there’s a country called China on our planet. The words most closely associated with the series are Harry Potter phenomenon–yes, it’s that big. The plot is simple: Bella, a high school student in whose voice the series is written, must choose between her two loves–the vampire Edward and the werewolf Jacob. The twist: vampires and werewolves are mortal enemies.

I’m not quite sure why this series is so wildly popular amongst teenage girls (its targeted demographic). We’ve all known a Bella in high school. She never had to ask for a ride.  All the boys wanted to protect her. She would break her thumb just when she’d volunteered to help. She always fainted if she stood too long in the sun. She always got lab partners who made sure her experiments always ran true and her equations resolved themselves. (I remember proving gravity worked at 9800 m/s/s).  

Anyway, any girl with a smidgen of feminist sensibility will long to give Bella a good swig of Skele-Grow so she can generate a spine. While the series is cast as a human versus vampire conflict, I think it’s more a gender struggle, inter-species romance notwithstanding. Edward is older, wiser, faster, a mind-reader, gorgeous, and immortal to boot, while Bella is a badly-co-ordinated young girl with a knack for getting into danger from which she must be rescued by an external agency. Bella seems to derive an atavistic pleasure from being a doormat, apart from grating attempts at assertiveness such as complaining about a dress or a too-expensive birthday gift.  Spoiler alert: In Breaking Dawn, the fourth (and last?) book, Bella is about to marry Edward, and go to Dartmouth (my old school!) and become a vampire. A virgin bride at eighteen, Bella gets pregnant after her wedding night, and decides to keep the baby (no surprise there). And it keeps getting worse; read and see.

Sexism, yes. But racism? Here’s an interesting take on Meyer’s work at author Alisa Valdes-Rodriguez blog. Valdes-Rodriguez writes:

Of primary concern for me is the treatment of Meyer’s main Native American character, Jacob Black. He is presented initially as a sweet, normal teen boy from the Paiute Reservation, but we soon learn that he is a werewolf, and that werewolves are the enemies of vampires. The vampires, at this point in the story, are shown to be European in origin, and as pale as pale can be – and friends to Bella, our human protagonist.

Jacob loves the irresistible Bella, just as Edward does, though he and his kind seem unable to resist their sinister nature the way the white vampires do. In the first two books, Bella is mildly drawn to Jacob (and even kisses him), particularly when Edward seems to lose interest in her. In the final book, Bella must choose between these two boys.

Naturally, she chooses the (white) vampire over the (brown) werewolf.

After reading the whole post, I’m not quite sure what I think. I didn’t pick up on some of the minor plot points in the book, but then, I didn’t really read the books closely (Bella’s hand-wringing got so tedious I skipped quite a bit).  I’m going to have to reserve judgement until I re-read the series. But this much I know: I’m a Jacobite. Edward–go take a gender studies class at Dartmouth.

5 responses to “Breaking Dawn by Stephenie Meyer

  1. Pingback: The Southern Vampire series by Charlaine Harris « BROWN PAPER

  2. i think meyer is a racist her last book really in my eyes proved that. Making the only black character in her book with a name the bad guy! not that i think people should attack her faith but to really feel you are better than anyone else is awful and ignorant. after reading great works by toni morrison i learned that every words written in a book means something and that you must read between the lines and that’s what i did with the twilight saga and saw the evil thinkings of meyer, i will never support her again.

  3. I can’t blame the girls for liking Twilight because it’ true anyway. It has a very good story and the characters are unique. Many people love this Twilight books and series.

  4. @ Jane: Toni Morrison is magnificent writer. I didn’t find Meyer’s work “evil”, but the books are definitely iffy, IMO.

  5. Just loved all of the books. Great characters and a familiar story of intence love against the odds. I have recently seen the films. Brilliant… beautiful young stars, great cinematics and a sound track that rocks!!! Cant wait for Eclipse, so i’ll just have to reread the book…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s